Did Sarah Jane Comrie Treat Black Patients? ‘Citi Bike Karen’ Video Places Spotlight On Bias In Health Care
The latest viral “Karen” video has sparked a discussion on social media well beyond the basic premise of a white woman weaponizing the color of her skin at the expense of a Black person.
While it’s true that all of that and then some were well on display when Sarah Jane Comrie was recently recorded falsely accusing a group of young Black men over a Citi Bike bikeshare rental in New York City, it was the place of employment of the Karen that prompted more questions than the Karen herself.
MORE: Sarah Jane Comrie Is A 2023 Version Of Carolyn Bryant
While Sarah Jane Comrie was busy trying to squeeze out tears that never actually materialized, crying for “help” from a threat she intentionally manufactured to falsely portray herself as a victim, her blue scrubs stood out just as much as her fake posturing.
Sarah Jane Comrie cannot be trusted to provide fare and impartial medical care to Black male patients of any age and Black patients in general. She cannot be trusted alone or with colleagues to treat them. Fire her immediately. She is a proven racist willing to lie against them.
— Our Sister Meghan (@oursistermeghan) May 15, 2023
Within hours of the video going viral over the weekend, eagle-eyed social media sleuths had not only uncovered her name but also confirmed she was employed by NYC Health + Hospitals, a fact that, for some, was just as alarming as her cruel and arguably racist actions toward the young Black men.
That unfortunate combination of a Karen working in health care prompted multiple variations of the same question: Has she been treating Black patients?
There are many concerns with the behavior of Internal Medicine PA Sarah Jane Comrie in this clip The biggest concern is how has she been treating her Black patients #NurseTwitter pic.twitter.com/321PzFeSuh
— Black Nurses Week (@blacknursesweek) May 15, 2023
The answer to that question isn’t immediately clear.
The implication, though, definitely is.
Of course, given Sarah Jane Comrie’s clear and apparent — and knowing — bias she intentionally employed against the young Black men in an effort to criminalize them because of her own wrongdoing, it’s not out of the realm of possibility that she could lend that same approach to a patient who looks like those same young Black men.
This makes me even madder because this woman is a PA. Sarah Jane Comrie. Imagine how she treats black patients in secrecy if she treats this black boy less than publicly. He could’ve became Emmitt Till in 2023 because of her fake “tears” https://t.co/fcPB0f2cVL
— Eric Mays Jr. (@reallyrc903) May 15, 2023
Implicit bias in heralthcare
To be sure, implicit bias in healthcare is a thing.
From Black maternal health to overall racial discrimination in health care and much more, statistics show that Black people routinely and disproportionately bear the brunt of such medical malpractice.
A report last year found that 27% of older Black and Latino adults have “experienced discrimination from health professionals, who either treated them unfairly or did not take their health concerns seriously because of their race or ethnicity.”
Sarah Jane Comrie should not be allowed to treat black patients and all of her former black patient files should be investigated for abuse and mistreatment at her hands. Fire #BikeKaren
— aka stardust (@a_k_a_stardust) May 16, 2023
In a glaring example, Medical News Daily reported how a “review from 2016 noted that some physicians were significantly more likely to recommend white patients for bypass surgery than Black patients. This difference was due to the physicians’ belief that their Black patients were not as well educated and so would not take part in the necessary physical activity after surgery.”
Even medical journals have been accused of downplaying Black people’s health issues in a subtle example of medical racism and implicit bias in health care.
It’s those types of biases that particularly harm Black people.
As a physician assistant, the capacity in which Sarah Jane Comrie worked before being placed on leave pending a review, the woman dubbed “Citi Bike Karen” certainly would have had the opportunity to employ such biases while on the clock.
I hope you interview Black and Brown patients whom Sarah Jane “Klanelda” Comrie treated and her Black and Brown coworkers as part of your review.
— Jay W. (#NoHateInNYC) Walker (@jaywwalker1) May 16, 2023
According to the American Academy of Physician Associates, a nonprofit advocacy group representing tens of thousands of “physician associates/physician assistants,” the group collectively known as “PAs” work as “licensed clinicians who practice medicine in every specialty and setting.” Expected to be “[t]rusted, rigorously educated and trained healthcare professionals, PAs are dedicated to expanding access to care and transforming health and wellness through patient-centered, team-based medical practice.”
Perhaps NYC Health + Hospitals and Bellevue Hospital, which placed Sarah Jane Comie on leave, will consider those harsh realities while determining her employment fate.
SEE ALSO:
‘Karen’ Video Shows White Woman Calling Cops On Black Men For Shoveling Snow On A Public Sidewalk